Is Calamari halal? Marine animals have different types and different tastes. They also come in different shapes and sizes.
So many giant creatures live in the ocean, which is beyond our imagination. Prophet Yunus (peace be upon him) swallowed such a big fish.
So many animal species live under the sea that finishing is challenging. But even if there are so many animals, is it halal to eat them?
But the common question about these marine animals is – is it halal to eat them? Is Calamari halal? We will discuss This answer in detail in today’s blog.
Is Calamari Halal?
Yes, calamari is Halal in Islam. Most jurists think it is halal to eat all kinds of marine animals. Considering this, eating Calamari is also halal. So Anyone can eat it without hesitation.
Thus, all marine animals, whether big or small, are halal: sharks, whales, crabs, dolphins, octopuses, snails, etc.
However, it is Haram to eat certain marine animals, such as frogs, crocodiles, etc., because there is an explicit prohibition in the hadith about these.
This is not a universally accepted opinion; some Islamic scholars have opined that eating Calamari is Haram.
They consider it permissible to eat only fish among sea creatures. All marine animals are Haram except fish. Among those who think Calamari haram are many famous Hanafi scholars.
Moreover, there are followers of other schools of thought; both sides have evidence from the Qur’an and Hadith, but we will discuss the acceptable and reasonable opinion at the end of the article.
Calamari halal in Quran?
Yes, calamari halal in Quran. In favor of Calamari halal, Islamic scholars present all the documents by which marine animals are halal because Calamari is like other marine animals.
In the Holy Quran, Allah Ta’ala says:
Translation: “Hunting and food of the sea has been made lawful for you.” (Surat al-Ma’idah: 96)
In another verse –
Translation: “Tell me – there is no haram food except the dead animals, the flowing blood and the meat of the pigs which have been revealed to me. Because it is unclean.” (Surat an-Nam – 5)
Calamari halal in Hadith
Although the hadith does not explicitly mention Calamari, it fundamentally declares Calamari as a halal hadith. You will get that proof from the following hadiths.
The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said:
Translation: “The water of the sea is sacred, and the dead animals there are also halal.” (Sunan Tirmidhi – 69)
In another hadith –
Translation: “All that Allah has made lawful in His Book is lawful, and all that He has made unlawful is unlawful.
To accept the forgiveness from Allah. Because Allah Tayala does not forget anything, he recited the following verse, “Do not forget your Lord” (Maryam – 64). (Silsilatus Sahihah – 2256)
The famous Shabi Shuraih – Radiyallahu Anhu – said eating all the animals in the water is lawful. ” (Sahih Bukhari 5/2091)
Moreover, one of the basic principles of Islam is that all worldly things are valid unless they are Haram in Islam.
Eating Calamari, crab, or turtle octopus is not Haram in the Quran and Hadith. So these are halal.
Is Calamari Halal Hanafi?
Calamari is not Halal in Hanafi. So It’s Haram to eat in Hanafi schools. To the Hanafis, eating only fish from the sea is halal. It is not halal to eat any other animal. And since Calamari is not a fish, eating it is not halal.
The above opinion of the Hanafis was that of the followers of the old Hanafi Madhhab. However, many followers of the contemporary Hanafi school consider Calamari halal.
The Hanafis are divided into three periods: ancient, medieval, and modern. Many of the views of the Hanafis of the old age were refuted by the Hanafis of the Middle Ages.
And many of the opinions of the Hanafis of the Middle Ages are being refuted by the Hanafis of the present age.
But their principles are the same and unchanged because many opinions change due to the change of era. But not the focus.
Why is Calamari Haram in Hanafi?
Adherents of the Hanafi school of thought generally argue for the prohibition of Calamari by the verses and hadiths that declare unclean animals to be Haram. For example,
In the Holy Quran, Allah Ta’ala says:
Translation: “He has made lawful for them what is lawful and unlawful for them.” (Surat al-A’raf: 156)
Allah Ta’ala has forbidden ‘Khabayes’ (dirty things) in that verse. It is called Khabayes, which is the natural hatred of human beings.
Meanwhile, Calamari hates human nature, so it belongs to the dirty stuff. And dirty things are Haram. So eating Calamari is also Haram.
Similarly, there is no record of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) or any of his Companions eating such marine animals.
In a further hadith, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) forbade any doctor to make medicine by killing frogs. (Abu Dawood – 361)
From all these verses and hadiths, it is clear that all kinds of sea creatures are Haram. Of these, Chalimari is particularly significant.
Summary of the answer
We have not found any document in the Qur’an or Sunnah that forbids Calamari. The documents that have been presented in the opinion of the Hanafi school are fragile.
Dirty things are forbidden in the Quran, but on what basis was the squid that the squid belonged?
Anyone can hate to eat Calamari. It’s a personal matter. But many people do not hate to eat Calamari. So one’s taste cannot be imposed on another.
However, if medical science proves harmful to the human body in the case of any marine animal, it will be Haram.
Because Islam does not support anything harmful to the human body. Whether it is marine or land.
My opinion
From the above discussion, it has been proved that eating marine animals is halal. So Calamari can be Halal. There is no evidence to call them Makrooh.
But if someone does not like to eat it, it is different. It’s a personal matter. But there is no reason to call them Haram or Makrooh.
The above words are the opinion of Imam Shafi and other Imams. However, the Hanafi school has different views on marine life.
FAQs
Is calamari halal for shia?
Whether Calamari is halal for Shia Muslims depends on their interpretation of Islamic dietary laws. Shia Muslims generally follow the same halal food principles as Sunni Muslims.
Is calamari halal sistani?
Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, one of the most prominent Shia scholars, has not made a specific ruling on the permissibility of Calamari.
Therefore, whether Calamari is acceptable for Shia Muslims who follow his rulings depends on their interpretation of Islamic dietary laws. Shia Muslims generally follow the same halal food principles as Sunni Muslims.
Is calamari halal sunni?
Yes, Calamari is generally halal for Sunni Muslims. According to Islamic dietary laws, seafood is halal, including squid, the main ingredient in Calamari.
However, it is essential to note that the method of obtaining and preparing the seafood must also be by Islamic guidelines for it to be considered halal.
Is calamari halal shafi?
Yes, Calamari is generally considered halal for Shafi’i Muslims. The Shafi’i school of thought follows the same principles of acceptable food as other Sunni Muslims, and seafood is considered halal, including squid, the main ingredient in Calamari.
However, it is essential to note that the method of obtaining and preparing the seafood must also be by Islamic guidelines for it to be considered halal.
Is calamari halal islamqa?
According to IslamQA, a famous Islamic website, Calamari is halal as long as it is obtained and prepared according to Islamic guidelines.
This includes ensuring that it is not mixed with any haram substances, such as alcohol or non-halal meat, and that it is not cooked using any utensils or equipment contaminated with haram substances.